A Nation of Whiners?

Today the Space Shuttle Columbia exploded over Texas while making its way to a landing in Florida, after a couple of weeks in space. Already there’s been an address from the President and half the mailing lists I’m on have sent out special “tragedy updates”, including even the Project Gutenberg mailing list. I asked Michael Hart, director of Project Gutenberg, why he used that mailing list to send out a message about the Columbia and he simply said “I sent to everyone I knew. . .”



But I don’t understand what we find so compelling as a nation about tragedies of this nature. When the Challenger exploded, killing all aboard, we as a nation went through an extended period of national hand-wringing and talking-head pontification on the unacceptable risks of the space program. I’m sure we’re going to experience this again, but …


Space travel is inherently dangerous. The astronauts on the Columbia were well aware of the danger, were trained professionals, and while it’s tragic that they died, well, it’s only seven people engaged in a dangerous profession.


By contrast, a few days ago a helicopter crashed in Afghanistan killing all four aboard. No-one cared, other the the immediate families. Like being an astronaut, being a soldier is inherently risky and dangerous, especially during times of great tension as they are in the Afghan region.


So the question I pose is: are we a nation of wimps? A bunch of whiners that cringe and cower at the slightest danger? Or what is it about these high profile accidents that engage the public interest so?


I take to heart the wisdom of my good friend from Israel, who after 9-11 said “the world is a dangerous place. I am not afraid; I live my life and believe strongly that is the best and most courageous response to terrorism, either here or in Israel.” My parents lived through the Battle of Britain and spent much of World War II in greater London during the worst of the Nazi bombing raids. Their response to 9-11 mirrored many others who lived through WWII: “this is shocking, but it’s not such a big deal. There is no true peace and you have to live your life…”


But by contrast, there were – and remain – people who are convinced that these are all signs of the coming Apocalypse and that the best move is to stock up on food and ammo and hide out in the mountains of rural Montana with your personal generator. And certainly, I expect the next week to be absolutely full of the horrible tragedy of the Columbia and its brave crew.


Sorry to sound like a curmudgeon, but given the content of the State of the Union address last week, the miserable economy, and the ever-closer threat of war with Iraq, aren’t there more important things for us to be thinking about and discussing on the national scene?

3 comments on “A Nation of Whiners?

  1. > And certainly, I expect the next week
    > to be absolutely full of the horrible
    > tragedy of the Columbia and its brave
    > crew.
    Interesting point, because two things happened in my life today related to the Columbia shuttle: First, I went to the local Halmark store to buy a card for a woman I started a company with in 1999 who lost her brother last week; he was the pilot William McCool on the shuttle. Second, I went to the grocery store and all the tabloids had front page pictures of either the crew or the white streaks that ran across the sky as the shuttle exploded. One in particular made reference to the last horrific moments of the crew. And I thought about that: My friend is having to deal with a tragic loss, and, on top of that, constant hounding by the media. Now she can’t even go to the grocery store without being reminded of her loss! Just a thought.
    P.S. Cool “Remember info” cookie-setter. 🙂

  2. I said the same thing at work – ‘why such a big deal about this when the helicopter that crashed was virtually ignored’ … didn’t go over well at all! I was reminded that NASA is a national program and of interest to the public … which I thought was what the military was also … and these were military people telling me this. Glad I wasn’t the only one who thought this!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.